Ben Hogan’s Secret: The Constant Mystery

A breakthrough in golf was made sixty-three years ago.  He discovered something that transformed him from a very good golfer to a legend in his lifetime, with an enduring reputation as the greatest ball striker the game has ever knownIt is.  Ben Hogan discovered something in 1946 and later insinuated and finally acknowledged that he had discovered a “secret”  A secret that enabled him to accomplish a goal he sought for nearly 14 years on the pro tour, namely how to produce a consistent, powerful, repeating swing that allowed him to gain almost total mastery over the golf ball.  Debates continue to this day over who is the greatest golfer of all time. But as Jack Nicklaus recently observed in response to a question about whether Tiger Woods is the best ball striker he had ever seen, “No, no that would unquestionably be Ben Hogan”.   We have probably all read that comment. “Terrible”Tommy Bolt was a legend in golf and famously noted that “All I know is I seen Nicklaus watching Hogan practice, but I ain’t never seen Hogan watch Nicklaus practice” 

For a number of years Hogan would only acknowledge that he had discovered a secret.  A number of professional golfers speculated about his secret in the 5 April 1954 Life Magazine.  The next year Hogan revealed his secret for all to see in the 8 August 1955 Life Magazine,  The article was entitled simply “This is my secret”, with Hogan detailing how he had further weakened his grip by moving his hands left so he could barely see 2 knuckles, with the V of both hands pointing right at the button of his chin.  I say further weakened his grip because he had previously moved his grip to the left or a neutral position in 1938 based on a tip to prevent hooking from Henry Picard.  Also, his thumb had been shortened upon his 1945 release.  He was able to control the club more effectively on the backswing with the shorter thumb. This helped him reduce his tendency to swing too fast. “John Daily it”Particularly with the driver.  He described the secret to his success as the Scottish method of deliberate pronation.  This technique involved a twisting or cupping of the left wrist on the backswing.  The move was believed to make it difficult to close the face of the club on the downswing, therefore preventing a hook.  It was a method that experts golfers believe is a great way to propel the ball into the air.  He explained how it worked. “supinated”His left wrist was twisted by the ball.  Hogan also said that the secret wouldn’t be worthwhile to an average golfer. It would ruin a poor golfer who already struggles with a slice.  Hogan won 33 majors and three tournaments between 1946 and his accident in his car on February 2, 1949.  This was a phenomenal run of success that took him to the pinnacle of the golf world.

 

One Secret Perceived.

 

Several months before the revelation of his secret in Life Magazine, Jack Fleck defeated Hogan in a playoff for the 1955 U.S. Open Championship.  Fleck was little heralded and lesser known and it is considered one of the greatest upsets in U.S. Open history.  Hogan was devastated by the loss, announcing that he would be a “ceremonial golfer”From that point on.  The win would have given him a record fifth US. Open Championship and atoned for his perception of being slighted by his win of the Hale Open in 1942, which was conducted like an Open in all but name, including the award of an identical medal that matched Hogan’s other four.  Hogan later released in the spring of 1957 a series of Sports Illustrated Articles that were later packaged into his classic instruction manual “Five Lessons, The Modern Fundamentals of Golf”. 

The book remains relevant and a classic over 52 years later.  Although the secret that was revealed in 1955 wasn’t contained within the book, there was much controversy about the book.  The subject was rarely or never discussed. “pronation”Except for the brief mention about the disastrous effects of pronation early on the downswing, the rest of this article is largely irrelevant.  This article contained a great deal of information. “supination”However,  With its focus on the basic golf fundamentals, Hogan’s philosophy held that proper application and practice of the basic elements of the swing was all that was needed.  The basic elements consisted of about 8 total movements that were linked together in a chain action to produce a repeating golf swing.  He felt that a golfer of average athletic ability could break 80.  The book failed to deliver the results promised, and golfers were skeptical.  On grip, there were 18 pages.  After all that coverage, the relatively weak grip advocated in Five Lessons was held up by many instructors as an example of a bad technique for beginners, as it exacerbated the bane of most golfers, the dreaded slice.  For golfers already prone to draw the ball, the focus on a strong adhesion of the right arm and elbow to the side, coupled with the inside swing, often produced the worst kind of confidence destroying shot, the snap or duck hook.  The recommendation to move the hips as fast as one could, as if they were attached to the wall by an elastic band, wreaked havoc on the swings of golfers whose arms could not keep pace with the body and often ended up swinging wildly or by tossing their arms through impact like a rag doll.  The book presented a crucial tenet in the swing as a breakthrough. However, it was too complicated, complex, and difficult to understand. 

 

What is the Book of Time Before and After?

 

Out of fairness to his book, a new breed of “franchise”Arnold Palmer, Gary Player and Jack Nicklaus were some of the leading golfers.  There were “swashbuckling”This was the era when golf was at its peak. Palmer had a go for broke swing that could only be produced by an athlete. Nicklaus with the flying right elbow was the reverse. “C”Hogan’s hero Bobby Jones called it “prodigious length”. “A style of golf with which I am not familiar” You can also do the opposite “C” gained prominence on the tour and the style was quite unlike that advocated in Five LessonsThis is a.  Despite Hogan’s reputation as a great ball striker and having achieved the admiration of his fellow golfers, Hogan’s style paled in comparison with Palmer.  Palmer’s golf was compelling, emotional, and it created a ground swell of fan support that became known as “Arnie’s Army”.  Arnie was the ideal golfer.  Palmer and Hogan did not get along, but Palmer insisted on using the term Palmer. “Fella”Palmer was annoyed throughout his life.  Palmer was irritated by the conservative approach to golf that Hogan used. Player started to become a strong force, and Nicklaus began to dominate.

 

The Secret:

 

Hogan ended his professional career with a hint of unfinished work.  There were hints that Hogan knew more about his game and his skills than was revealed by his books on golf or Life Magazine.  He was frequently described as “Henny Bogan”He was jokingly referring to himself when he spoke on the phone or met people.  A December 1984 interview he conducted with Nick Seitz was included as a preface to the reprintings of Five Lessons, which had just turned 30 years old.  Hogan discussed the importance and trials that lead him to this discovery.  He also insisted that he “would not change a thing in Five Lessons and that everything he knew about the full golf swing was in there”It is.  These statements were questioned and speculated upon again, as the book did not mention the secret he had revealed in 1955.  Hogan offered to disclose his true secret sometime in the next decade. This was allegedly done over the course the next ten years.  The technique was rumored to allow professionals to shoot in the 50s.  The price for the technique was reported to be $100,000.  However, the deal did not materialize.  Although there was an update in the magazine that covered much of what was known about the secret to golf, it did not contain any new information.

 

New Secrets

 

Hogan never revealed any additional information during his life.  Over the past decade, a number of books were published by people who are credible and claim to have learned Hogan’s secrets.  Although many stories are interesting, some of these books may be fiction. In other cases, the secret is revealed by focusing on the Five Lessons fundamentals.  Many speculate that Hogan wasn’t trying to reveal anything more and was simply dragging people along.  Others have difficulty explaining why, if there was more to the story, an honorable man with integrity like Hogan did not reveal it in his lifetime.  Others speculate that Hogan knew the secret, but it wasn’t. “began with a P and ended with an E”Practice.  Byron Nelson claimed it was hitting it near the hole and making the putts.  Some others argued that any secret was no longer necessary with modern technology, the increased focus on distance golf and targeting the target.  Jim McLean stated in The Ben Hogan Collection DVD, that Ben Hogan was really just a collection of small things.  It is possible that this may not be the whole truth.

Exit mobile version